My First Castle Panic

Never Miss Everything Board Game posts again! Get them in your inbox:

All images courtesy of the My First Castle Panic BoardGameGeek.com page.


Quick Look: My First Castle Panic

Designer:  Justin DeWitt
Artists: Cam Kendell
Publisher: Fireside Games
Year Published: 2019

No. of Players: 1-4

Ages: 4+

Playing Time: 20 minutes


Find more info on BoardGameGeek.com  


From the Publisher:

My First Castle Panic, like its predecessor Castle Panic, is a co-operative game in which players work together to defend their castle, but this game removes the reading requirement of the earlier one and fosters the development of educational skills, such as identifying colors and shapes, problem solving, and turn taking.

In the game, monsters follow a single path toward a single, large, eye-catching castle, which is protected by one wall. Each step toward the castle is identified by a color and a shape. Players hold cards in their hands with cute defenders who also have a color and shape. When a card is played that matches the location of the monster, that monster is captured and thrown in the dungeon. Tension builds as more monsters are placed and move along the path toward the castle. If the castle is destroyed, the players lose; if it still stands when all the monsters are in the dungeon, the players win.

Disclaimer: The publisher provided the copy of My First Castle Panic.. The opinions expressed in the review are completely my own.



My love for Justin DeWitt’s Castle Panic runs deep. I have all the expansions and promos for Fireside Game’s evergreen classic. The Son and I have played many games of various difficulty. So, when My First Castle Panic came out, I was not initially interested. The Son was too old for it. But now, I have The Daughter. She is three, and she really wants to play games with us. As you can guess, she is just not ready for most games. My First Castle Panic came back into my line of sight, and I figured now was the time to get it. I am so grateful that I did not pick it up when it first debuted in 2019. It would not have made the impact that it has now. If you have a little gamer in your life, My First Castle Panic is a must have in your collection.


Rules & Setup:

The setup for My First Castle Panic is very simple. Set the board in the middle of the table. Find the three monster tokens with a star on them and place them in the first three spaces on left side of the board. Shuffle and deal one card to each player. Place the remaining monster tokens in a pile or draw bag. Youngest player goes first.

The rules are just as simple. The active player draws the top card of the deck then may either play one of their cards that matches the color and shape of one of the spaces occupied by a monster, or they can ask someone else to play their card that matches. If a card can be played, the monster is dispatched to the dungeon, which is the bottom of the box.

Theme and Mechanics:

The theme and mechanics practically match the Castle Panic game. There are monsters coming in from the woods bent on destroying your castle. You must work together to defeat the monsters and send them to the dungeon (the bottom of the box).



Players take turns playing as I mentioned above. Some special cards and monsters appear in the game.

There are two special types of cards: Hero Cards and Any-Color Cards. Hero Cards can be played on any shape matching color, while an Any-Color Card can be played on any color a matching shape. Only one card may be played per turn.

A card might also depict a booting kicking a monster. This card dispatches any monster on the board back to the draw pile. A wall building card allows a player to rebuild the wall, protecting the castle.

Once the one card, or no card, has been played, the monsters move forward one space, and a new monster is drawn and placed on the first spot. However, if the monster drawn and placed is one of the three special ones, more must be done. A runner goes all the way to front of the monster line. Another type pushes all monsters an additional space. And lastly, one might push all the monsters forward an additional space and require yet another monster drawn!

If at any time, a monster hits the wall, the monster is captured and sent to the dungeon, but he has destroyed the wall, and it is also removed from the game. If the wall is gone and a new monster runs into the castle, well, the castle is destroyed, and the players lose the game. However, through teamwork and cooperation, if all 16 monsters are dispatched to the dungeon, the castle is safe, and everyone wins!

Artwork and Components:

Being a children’s game, the artwork by Can Kendall fits the bill. The Daughter loves the little monsters, though she is concerned why the runner monster has a band-aid on its head. Component-wise, all the tokens, castle, wall, and board are made from a nice thick chipboard which will hold up to a lot of playing. Which is great because it is going to see some table time in my house. The cards are larger than the base game and nicely designed to show the color and shape as well as having a hero on it.

The Good:

My First Castle Panic teaches young gamers three shapes, three colors, how to match, how to ask for help, and how to take turns. These lessons are all fundamental to life. My daughter, who just turned three, loves this game. She now refers to it as her game. She will take it off the shelf and start setting it up on her own. She knows that she needs me to shuffle the cards, but other than that, she does it all. She asks her brother, mother, and me to join her. All of this is “The Good,” and on top of it all, it is a genuine joy to play with youngsters.

We have played this game many times, and we win about 66% of the time. I think it is simply great that the game does win a good percentage of the time. This allows youngsters to learn that even trying hard can still result in a loss. The Daughter still has fun playing, but she accepts that she won’t always win.

The Other:

My only real problem with My First Castle Panic is that it is so short. I wish that it was a double-sided board with a slightly longer track for when The Daughter gets a little older. And maybe, Justin DeWitt can come up with a fun expansion or add-on for the game. Who knows? The game is perfect as it is, for who it is intended for.


Final Thoughts:

I will always be grateful for this game as The Daughter refers to it as “her game.” She will go get it out and start to set it up. It has already given us a lot of enjoyment, and I look forward to more fun times with her. The Son loves to play it with us, too. It has become a great time for me and the kids. I must keep reminding him that she is not quite ready for Castle Panic, and let’s just keep playing My First Castle Panic with her for now. Watching her pick up the defeated monsters and throwing them in dungeon while saying, “Into the dungeon!” will never get old. She will get old, but this memory will not. I urge you to get this game for your children, nieces, nephews, grandchildren, or any child that you spend time with. You will not regret it.


Players Who Like:

Playing games with their children, Parents who want to move on from Candy Land

After reading Adam’s review, if this sounds like a game for you at the time of this posting My First Castle Panic is available for purchase go check it out and get it HERE.
Find out more at BGG
Did you get it based on our review? Please comment below letting us know!


Do you find that you’re missing too many reviews as we drop them? Provide your name and email below and we’ll keep you in the know of what we reviewed that week as well as other hot news!!!!!

Marketing permission: I give my consent to to be in touch with me via email using the information I have provided in this form for the purpose of news, updates and marketing.What to expect: If you wish to withdraw your consent and stop hearing from us, simply click the unsubscribe link at the bottom of every email we send or contact us at gettinggeekywithgamerleaf@gmail.com. We value and respect your personal data and privacy. To view our privacy policy, please visit our website. By submitting this form, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with these terms.

Check out Stringamajig and Fireside Games on:








Adam Collins – Reviewer


Adam Collins plays many games. Too many games if you ask his wife. Not enough games if you ask his kids. Adam also designs games for his publishing company Bearded Board Games. He also runs a podcast, Eat Lunch and Board Game, where he reviews games on their merits include their ability to be played over a lunch hour. He also interviews other people involved in various facets of the board gaming community: designers, podcasters, authors, cross stitch designers. He grew up playing games, revived the passion ten years ago, and hasn’t turned back.

See Adam’s reviews HERE.
Never Miss Everything Board Game posts again! Get them in your inbox:

1 Comment

  1. Greg L
    December 23, 2021 / 9:54 am

    I enjoy playing castle panic and this looks like a good adaptation that I could play with my grandkids. They really enjoy games too.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *